Publication Ethics and Malpractice Policy

General ethical requirements for preparing, evaluating and publishing scholarly materials, participants’ responsibilities and principles for responding to potential misconduct.

01. Purpose and scope

This policy establishes the ethical framework for the journal “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics”. It applies to authors, editors, editorial board members, reviewers and the publisher’s staff; it covers submitted manuscripts, accompanying materials and published works, including special-issue content if such issues are organised.

The journal’s founder is the National Research University “Tashkent Institute of Irrigation and Agricultural Mechanization Engineers” (hereafter the Institute), and its publisher is I-EDU GROUP LLC. The Institute provides the organisational conditions for the journal’s operation while preserving the independence of decisions on individual manuscripts.

In addressing ethical matters, the editorial office uses applicable guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), including its Core Practices, and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing developed by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA and WAME.

02. Core principles

  • Research integrity. Methods, observations, calculations and conclusions must be reported accurately, acknowledging research limitations and others’ contributions.
  • Impartial assessment. Scientific soundness, significance, relevance to the journal’s scope and ethical acceptability determine editorial decisions. Citizenship, sex, origin, beliefs, position or an author’s affiliation with the Institute confer no advantage and are not grounds for discrimination. Negative or statistically non-significant results are not by themselves grounds for rejection.
  • Responsibility and transparency. Participants disclose material interests and sources of support, respond to substantiated questions and help correct the scholarly record.
  • Confidentiality and respect. Unpublished materials are protected against improper use; interactions are professional, without threats, humiliation or pressure.
  • No guarantee of acceptance. Payments, fee waivers, financial support, issue plans or administrative instructions do not replace scientific assessment or justify lower ethical standards.

Inclusive and respectful scholarly language. Authors must use precise and respectful scholarly language, avoiding stereotypes and discriminatory or degrading expressions. Individual and group characteristics should be stated only where scientifically relevant to the research. This requirement does not limit justified scholarly criticism or objective reporting of findings.

03. Responsibilities of participants

Authors

Authors are responsible for the reliability of the work they submit, accurate use of sources and lawful use of data, images, software code and other materials. All coauthors must be aware of the submission, approve the final manuscript and accept responsibility for the work. Contributions must be accurately described; manuscript preparation services do not entitle anyone to conceal actual authors or sell authorship.

At submission, authors disclose related previous work, financial and non-financial interests, funding and other material support, and the role of supporting organisations. Absence of funding and conflicts of interest must also be stated. Authors provide data-availability information and assist verification of findings on reasonable request, subject to lawful and ethical access restrictions.

Where the nature of the research requires ethics approval, permits or informed consent, authors obtain them and report them in the manuscript; any applicable exemption from ethical review must be justified and documented. On discovering a material error, authors promptly notify the editorial office and cooperate in its assessment, including after publication.

Editors and editorial board

Editors ensure substantive manuscript assessment, independent peer review, conflict-of-interest management and reasoned decisions. They do not exploit unpublished information, demand unjustified citations or ignore substantiated reports of errors. Responsibility for the decision rests with an authorised editor, not a reviewer, administrative employee or automated system. The journal’s editorial oversight continues when guest editors are involved.

Reviewers

Reviewers accept assignments within their expertise, disclose interests that could affect assessment in advance and meet agreed deadlines or report delays. Comments must be reasoned and respectful. Potential misconduct is reported to the editor; reviewers do not publicly accuse authors independently or use peer review to promote their own publications. Delegating an assignment requires prior editorial permission and confidentiality safeguards.

Founder and publisher

The Institute and I-EDU GROUP LLC support the editorial office, ethics procedures and independent consideration of disputed cases. Financial and administrative support is separate from article-acceptance decisions. Those making manuscript decisions do not decide on payments or fee waivers; their remuneration and that of staff must not depend on the number of accepted articles. The founder and publisher do not demand publication of particular work or obstruct justified corrections for reputational or financial reasons.

04. Independence in cases of conflicts of interest

Authors disclose interests relevant to the work at submission; editors and reviewers disclose theirs before review begins. A material interest discovered later is reported without delay. Disclosure alone does not establish misconduct; its nature, impact and necessary management measures are assessed.

An editor who is an author of the work or has a significant conflict of interest is recused from handling it. That editor does not select reviewers, participate in discussions or decisions, or gain official access to confidential review materials. As an author, the editor receives only the information ordinarily given to an author under the journal’s review model.

The review is assigned to a competent editor without the relevant conflict. Holding the position of deputy editor-in-chief does not by itself demonstrate independence. Where reporting relationships, collaboration or the Institute’s interests could influence the process, an editor from another organisation is appointed. Independent assessment also applies to allegations against the editor-in-chief, editorial board members or publisher; conflicted persons do not adjudicate complaints about their own conduct.

05. Unacceptable practices

The journal prohibits conduct that distorts authorship, provenance, reliability or independent evaluation of scholarly work. Such conduct includes:

  • Fabrication and falsification: invented observations, measurements or sources; substitution of data; unjustified removal of results; manipulation of images, graphs or calculations that creates a false impression of the research.
  • Plagiarism and undisclosed reuse: appropriation of others’ text, ideas, data, translations or code; presenting a substantial part of one’s own published work as new without disclosure and citation.
  • Duplication: simultaneous consideration of the same or substantially overlapping manuscripts by multiple journals; concealed republication, including in translation; artificial fragmentation of results accompanied by misleading claims of novelty.
  • Manipulation of authorship and identity: buying or selling positions in author lists, fictitious or undisclosed authorship, falsified affiliations, consents or documents, and use of paper-mill services.
  • Manipulation of review and citation: fictitious reviewers, fabricated peer reviews, coordinated attempts to circumvent independent assessment, pressure on editors and demands for irrelevant citations to inflate metrics.
  • Concealment of material circumstances: deliberate failure to disclose interests, funding, required permissions or the use of artificial intelligence tools where disclosure is required by journal policy; violation of research participants’ rights and confidentiality.

The existence of a disclosed preprint, thesis or conference abstract does not itself establish misconduct. Authors must report such materials and overlaps; submission eligibility is assessed under the originality and repository policies. An honest error, reasoned scholarly disagreement or an unconfirmed hypothesis is not automatically misconduct, although a significant error may require correction or retraction.

06. Confidentiality and digital tools

Access to manuscripts, reviews, personal data and correspondence is limited to persons who need it for editorial work or proper consideration of an ethical concern. Materials are not disclosed to outsiders or used for personal, academic or commercial advantage.

Editors and reviewers are prohibited from uploading confidential manuscripts, excerpts, reviews or unpublished data to external generative AI services, including services described as private. Agreement with an editor does not waive this prohibition. An AI tool cannot be an author, reviewer or party bearing editorial responsibility. A text-similarity score or AI detector result alone is not proof of misconduct: substantive human assessment is required.

07. Reporting possible misconduct

Authors, reviewers, readers and representatives of organisations may report possible misconduct before or after publication. Reports should identify the work title, DOI, link or manuscript number, describe the specific concern and provide available supporting materials. A reporter need not prove misconduct in advance; sufficient information to assess whether the concern is substantiated is enough.

Substantive anonymous reports are assessed on their merits; lack of contact information may limit clarification and feedback. Good-faith reporting must not lead to retaliation, pressure or an adverse editorial decision against the reporter.

The reporter’s identity and investigation information are protected to the extent compatible with a fair process and applicable disclosure obligations. Absolute anonymity cannot be guaranteed where disclosure is necessary and justified. Concerns about the editor-in-chief or publisher may be addressed through the Institute’s official contacts with a request for independent review.

08. Fair investigation and protection of the scholarly record

A report is registered and preliminarily assessed by an authorised person without a conflict of interest. The relevance and sufficiency of evidence are examined; affected parties have the opportunity to explain circumstances and provide documentation. An allegation is not treated as an established fact. Where necessary, the editorial office requests underlying data, review records or an independent expert opinion.

An independent committee may be established for complex cases; external specialists take part where an institutional conflict exists. The editorial office decides questions about publication reliability and editorial process but does not substitute for an investigation by the research institution. Where justified, it contacts the relevant institution or other competent party, sharing only necessary information.

Before publication, the journal may suspend consideration, request corrections or reject a manuscript on established grounds. After publication, a proportionate response is chosen: correction, expression of concern or retraction. The aim is to maintain a reliable scholarly record and inform readers. Retraction may also be required for a serious honest error; it is not an automatic determination that all authors are culpable.

Substantive changes are not made silently. A public notice must explain the basis for a decision and be linked to the relevant article; evidence, correspondence and decisions are documented. The reporter and affected parties receive information on progress and outcomes within confidentiality limits. Procedural complaints or appeals are examined by someone uninvolved in the original decision. Detailed stages, deadlines, grounds and notice formats are specified in the related policies below.

International guidance

COPE Core Practices and the Principles of Transparency are used as methodological guidance. The journal’s own requirements and accountability for their implementation are established by this and related policies.

Back to top


ISSN 2181-4546 (Online)