Editorial Board Policy

The editorial board ensures the journal’s scientific expertise and professional development. This policy defines the requirements for its composition, appointment, participation and performance evaluation, as well as procedures for renewing appointments and publicly presenting board members.

01. Purpose and status of the editorial board

The editorial board of “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics” brings together specialists who contribute to developing the journal’s scientific profile, maintaining publication quality and improving editorial operations. Membership requires substantive participation, not merely the appearance of a name on the website.

The founder is the National Research University “Tashkent Institute of Irrigation and Agricultural Mechanization Engineers” (hereafter the Institute), and the publisher is I-EDU GROUP LLC. The Institute formally appoints board members on the basis of a reasoned recommendation by the Editor-in-Chief. Appointment of the Editor-in-Chief and relationships between the editorial office and the founder are governed by the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy.

This document governs membership of the board. Its membership list is published separately on the “Editorial Board” page. Membership alone does not confer authority to make decisions on all manuscripts or access the entire editorial archive.

02. Composition and selection criteria

The board must comprise at least five specialists with verifiable qualifications and must not consist exclusively of staff from a single organisation. Its size and distribution of expertise are determined in relation to the journal’s scope, manuscript volume and actual workload.

  • Subject expertise: research and publication experience in geodesy, cartography and geoinformatics or related disciplines covered by the journal’s aims and scope; expertise in methodology, modelling and data analysis where needed.
  • Professional integrity: willingness to follow editorial rules, disclose significant interests and provide reasoned evaluations of scientific work.
  • Practical availability: sufficient time for agreed tasks, effective communication with the editorial office and proficiency in the language required for assigned work.
  • Diversity of scientific approaches: participation by specialists from different organisations, regions and research traditions consistent with the journal’s scope and audience. International participation must be supported by actual work.

Academic degrees, positions, citation metrics or reputation do not replace an assessment of relevant expertise and willingness to contribute. Membership cannot be purchased and is not conditional on attracting paid submissions, publishing one’s own articles or promising to increase the journal’s citations.

03. Nomination, verification and consent

Candidates may be nominated by the Editor-in-Chief, current board members and research organisations; individual specialists may also apply. Candidates provide a professional biography, current affiliation, principal research areas, examples of relevant publications and details of other editorial responsibilities.

The editorial office verifies identity and qualifications through available institutional profiles, publications and direct correspondence. ORCID and other identifiers help establish identity but do not replace substantive verification. An unresolved allegation of misconduct is assessed on its merits and is not, by itself, proof of wrongdoing.

Before appointment, candidates receive a description of their role, expected workload, limits of authority, term and conditions for renewal or termination. Written consent, including confirmation by email, is mandatory. Name, affiliation and role are published only after consent and formal appointment. Honorary or former membership, where shown, is distinguished from the active board and must not be represented as current editorial work.

04. Term of appointment and induction

New appointments and renewals made after this policy takes effect have a three-year term. The appointment document records the start and end dates. Reappointment may occur repeatedly following evaluation of contributions and the journal’s needs; renewal is not automatic. Existing appointments are reviewed at the next board review without retrospectively changing their dates.

Before work begins, the editorial office introduces new members to the journal’s scope, current policies and working procedures. Roles involving manuscript handling require clarification of decision-making limits and necessary training in OJS. Access is granted individually and only for assigned tasks; sharing accounts is prohibited.

Agreed tasks and expected workload are recorded at appointment and revised when necessary. Board members promptly report extended unavailability, changes of affiliation or inability to complete assignments so that work can be reassigned.

05. Roles and allocation of responsibilities

  • Editor-in-Chief coordinates the board, identifies expertise needs, proposes its composition and organises participation reviews. Responsibility for editorial decisions and delegation is established by the governance and peer-review policies.
  • Deputy Editor-in-Chief performs specifically delegated functions and coordinates particular areas. The deputy’s position alone does not ensure independence in the presence of a conflict of interest.
  • Section or handling editor, where appointed, handles assigned materials within their qualifications and documented authority. The appointment specifies whether the editor provides recommendations or makes final decisions.
  • Board members without decision-making authority advise on subject areas and methods, suggest appropriate experts, discuss publication quality and help review policies. Their recommendations do not replace decisions by an authorised editor.
  • Editorial secretariat manages correspondence, assignment records and the accuracy of publicly displayed information; technical processing does not confer the right to make scientific decisions.

Tasks are allocated according to competence, independence and availability. Collective voting by the board does not replace the prescribed decision process for an individual article. Discussion of organisational matters does not grant access to confidential manuscripts not assigned to participants.

06. Practical participation and professional boundaries

At least once a year, the board holds a working discussion in person, remotely or through documented written consultation. It examines the relevance of published content to the journal’s scope, needs for new expertise, the quality of editorial work and proposals for journal development. Outcomes, responsible persons and agreed actions are recorded.

Members help identify qualified experts and inform the scientific community about the journal without intrusive mass mailings or promises of acceptance. They do not demand scientifically unjustified citations to their own work or the journal and do not evaluate colleagues by acceptance rates or publication revenue.

Information about unpublished work is used solely for assigned editorial tasks. Confidentiality and digital-tools requirements are governed by the relevant policies and continue after membership ends. Members may not delegate their authority to assistants or use the board’s name to approve publication without permission.

07. Other commitments and participation in publications

On appointment and whenever significant changes occur, members inform the Editor-in-Chief of other editorial roles, related commitments and significant interests. Holding multiple roles is allowed where agreed duties can be fulfilled and no unmanageable conflict arises. Participation in decisions on the same manuscript at different journals, or use of confidential information to divert submissions, is prohibited. Matters concerning the Editor-in-Chief are referred to an independent responsible person under the governance policy.

Articles authored by board members are handled in accordance with the Peer Review Policy by an independent handling editor, without involvement of the interested individual in processing or decisions. Membership offers no advantage in acceptance or publication timing.

The editorial office ensures that research articles with at least one author who is an editor, board member or reviewer of the journal do not exceed 25% of published research articles in each of the two most recent issues considered separately. Each article counts once regardless of the number of such authors. Checks occur when preparing an issue; board composition and membership history must not be changed to evade this limit. The rule does not replace scientific evaluation or create a guaranteed quota for authors associated with the editorial office.

08. Evaluation, renewal and termination of membership

At least annually, the Editor-in-Chief organises an evaluation of participation, covering agreed tasks, the quality of advice, timeliness, disclosure of interests and currency of expertise. Actual workload, availability and justified interruptions are considered. Evaluation informs changes of role, further training, renewal or changes in composition; numbers of accepted articles and personal citation metrics are not independent measures of performance quality.

Membership may end following written resignation, expiry without renewal, persistent inability to perform duties, an unmanageable conflict of interest or an established material breach of obligations. Where insufficient participation is questioned, the circumstances and possible reassignment of duties are first examined. Before an adverse decision, the person is informed of the grounds and given a reasonable opportunity to respond.

Access may be temporarily restricted or a member removed from a particular assignment during an investigation to protect the process; this does not establish misconduct. The Institute formally approves a final membership change following a documented review from which interested parties are excluded. Good-faith disagreement on scientific matters, refusal to accept a weak article or reporting a concern are not grounds for removal. Objections are considered under the Complaints and Appeals Policy.

On departure, unfinished assignments are transferred to an authorised editor, access rights are reviewed and the public board list is updated. Editorial records remain preserved with appropriate access restrictions; departure does not justify deleting the history of editorial decisions.

09. Public information and accuracy of board membership

The “Editorial Board” page lists each current member’s full name, editorial role, current institution and country. Where possible, an institutional profile and verified ORCID are added; subject expertise helps readers understand the board’s relevance to the journal’s scope. The date of the page’s last update and the official editorial contact channel are displayed.

Membership and roles must match across all language versions of the website. The secretariat verifies information at least annually and updates it following confirmed changes without waiting for the next scheduled review. Personal contacts and other non-public information are not published without consent. If a member prefers communication through the editorial office, professional correspondence is forwarded through that channel.

10. Related policies and implementation

The Peer Review Policy governs the review model and manuscript decisions; the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy allocates governance responsibilities; the Conflicts of Interest Policy governs recusals. Ethical allegations and appeals are handled under separate policies on misconduct, complaints and appeals. This page does not replace those procedures.

Enquiries about membership, correcting information and agreed duties are sent through the journal’s contact page: https://journals.tiiame.uz/GCG/ru/about/contact. This document applies after approval and official publication. Approval dates and subsequent changes are recorded in editorial records; a new version must not misrepresent previous board composition or work performed earlier.

Reference guidance

Applicable COPE recommendations and published criteria for transparency and quality of scholarly journals inform the composition and evaluation of the editorial board. The appointment and working conditions set out below are the journal’s internal rules.

Back to top


ISSN 2181-4546 (Online)