Conflicts of Interest Policy
Transparent disclosure of interests helps ensure independent and fair assessment of scholarly work. This policy defines interests relevant to publication, participants’ responsibilities, procedures for assessing interests, management measures and actions when undisclosed circumstances are identified.
Contents
- Definition and scope
- Circumstances requiring disclosure
- Disclosure period, timing and recipients
- Author declarations and their publication
- Funding and the role of supporting parties
- Participation of editors and reviewers
- Assessment of interests and management measures
- Interests of the journal, founder and publisher
- Undisclosed interests before and after publication
- Confidentiality, enquiries and implementation
01. Definition and scope
A conflict of interest arises when financial, personal, professional or institutional circumstances may influence scientific judgement or may reasonably be perceived as doing so. Both actual and potential interests must be disclosed; evidence of actual bias is not required for disclosure.
These rules apply to authors, reviewers, editors, guest editors, editorial board members, participating staff, the founder and the publisher of “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics”. They apply to all types of materials, including special issues, before and after publication.
A disclosed interest does not in itself constitute misconduct or result in automatic rejection of an article. However, disclosure does not automatically resolve a conflict: recusal or other measures are required when there is a significant risk. When in doubt, participants report the circumstances to the editorial office rather than independently declaring them immaterial.
02. Circumstances requiring disclosure
- Financial: employment, consultancy, fees, ownership interests, patents, royalty income, paid travel, equipment or other benefits from organisations interested in the results.
- Professional and academic: recent coauthorship, joint projects, academic supervision, employment dependence, direct competition for the same resource or contract, or involvement in a dispute connected with the research.
- Personal: close family or other relationships, serious personal disputes or circumstances that may impair impartiality.
- Institutional: an organisation’s interest in a technology, research object, funding, contract or findings; a participant’s administrative role in such an organisation.
- Other significant interests: public representation of an interested party, involvement in decisions on the matter under consideration, or beliefs directly related to the subject of the work that may influence assessment.
For example, relationships with the supplier of geodetic equipment under investigation, the owner of a geoinformation technology being analysed, the commissioning party for a cartographic project assessment or an organisation interested in modelling results must be evaluated. The list is not exhaustive.
Working in the same scientific field or expressing reasoned disagreement with conclusions does not in itself establish a conflict. Personal information and beliefs without a justified connection to the work under review are not requested. No monetary threshold is set below which disclosure of a work-related financial relationship is automatically unnecessary.
03. Disclosure period, timing and recipients
Direct support for a particular study must be reported for the entire period of its preparation and conduct. For other related relationships, the standard disclosure period is the preceding 36 months at the date of submission or acceptance of an editorial assignment. Earlier circumstances must also be disclosed if their influence continues, such as an active patent, continuing dependence or an unresolved dispute.
- Authors disclose information at initial submission and update it upon material change, before final acceptance and during proof checking.
- Reviewers inform the handling editor of relevant relationships before accepting an invitation; if discovered later, they suspend assessment and notify the editor.
- Editors and editorial board members submit declarations on appointment, confirm their accuracy at least annually and additionally review their interests before individual assignments.
- Staff and publisher representatives disclose significant interests before participating in a decision, accessing sensitive materials or reviewing a complaint.
New circumstances are reported without delay, including after publication. Information concerning the Editor-in-Chief’s interests is sent to an independent responsible person under the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy; an interested person does not assess their own conflict.
05. Funding and the role of supporting parties
Research funding information and the declaration of interests are separate sections. The absence of a conflict does not remove the obligation to disclose a grant, institutional, material or other support. An absence of funding must also be explicitly stated in the funding section.
Authors describe the supporting party’s role in defining the research question, selecting methods, collecting and analysing data, interpreting results, drafting the text and deciding to submit. If the supporting party did not participate in these activities, this must be stated. Naming an equipment supplier or data provider only in acknowledgements does not replace disclosure of a significant relationship.
Restrictions on authors’ access to data, verification of results or independent presentation of findings must be disclosed. An editor may confidentially request relevant terms of an agreement. If reliability cannot be assessed because of an interested party’s irremovable control, consideration may be suspended or the article rejected with an explanation; commercial funding alone is not grounds for rejection.
06. Participation of editors and reviewers
A reviewer is not appointed if they work at the same organisation as any author, have coauthored with an author or collaborated closely on research during the preceding three years, or have another significant conflict. These rules also apply to experts suggested by authors. Earlier relationships are assessed according to their continuing influence.
An editor must not handle their own work, materials by close associates, work involving direct employment dependence, significant financial interests or another relationship that precludes independent assessment. Coauthorship and close collaboration during the preceding three years are grounds for recusal. Shared organisational affiliation between an editor and author is disclosed and assessed separately; it does not override the stricter prohibition applying to reviewers.
When an editor is recused, another competent editor is appointed. If reassignment within the journal does not remove dependence or the risk of institutional influence, an editor from another organisation is engaged. Appointment procedures, access restrictions and decision-making independence are defined in the governance and peer-review policies.
Double anonymity does not guarantee an absence of conflicts. If a reviewer recognises an author or identifies a significant relationship, they report it without independently searching for the author’s identity. A review by an interested person does not count as an independent expert assessment required for accepting an article.
07. Assessment of interests and management measures
The assessment is conducted by a responsible editor without a conflict of interest. The editor determines the relationship between the interest and the work, the nature of potential influence, the participant’s role and whether proposed measures are sufficient. The declarant’s self-assessment is considered but does not replace an editorial decision.
- If a circumstance is unrelated to the work, the basis for this conclusion is recorded; excessive personal information is not published.
- Where an author has a significant interest, the public declaration is clarified; additional methodological information, data or independent expertise may be requested.
- Where an editor or reviewer has a significant conflict, recusal and replacement are required rather than merely publishing a declaration.
- If the influence affected an assessment already completed, the need for a new independent review is examined.
- If adequate independence or verifiability cannot be ensured, the editorial office explains any suspension or rejection and provides information about appeals.
The decision, prescribed measures and responsible persons are documented. Additional scrutiny is not a punishment for good-faith disclosure. Disclosure of an author’s interest does not justify lowering reliability standards or cancelling independent peer review.
08. Interests of the journal, founder and publisher
The Institute as founder and I-EDU GROUP LLC as publisher disclose the journal’s organisational affiliation and sources of support relevant to its activities. Agreements, partnerships and institutional obligations that may influence a specific publication are disclosed to an independent handling editor; circumstances material to readers are reflected in public information about the journal or article.
Coverage of authors’ expenses, payments, advertising relationships or interests in journal metrics do not determine scientific decisions. Those making decisions on an article do not decide its payments or fee waivers; remuneration does not depend on article acceptance. The practical separation of functions is governed by the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy.
Current brief information about significant editorial, professional and financial interests relating to journal work is published for editors and editorial board members. When their own articles are published, their relevant role is disclosed and independent assessment is indicated without identifying anonymous reviewers.
09. Undisclosed interests before and after publication
Any participant or reader may report a possible omission. The editorial office verifies the information and requests an explanation from the person concerned. A report alone proves neither a conflict nor intentional concealment; the facts, significance and influence on the work or its assessment are evaluated.
Before publication, the editorial office may suspend the process, obtain a revised declaration, replace an interested participant and arrange reassessment. Once the issue has been resolved, consideration continues under ordinary scientific criteria. Where intentional concealment is suspected, the Policy on Allegations of Misconduct applies.
After publication, if an omission is confirmed without affecting reliability, a correction of the declaration linked to the article is published. If data, conclusions or independence of assessment are affected, the need for further action is determined under the Corrections, Retractions and Post-Publication Updates Policy. An undisclosed interest does not automatically result in retraction; the decision depends on the established impact.
Where necessary, the editorial office asks the relevant research organisation to investigate. Participants and the reporter are informed of the outcome within permissible limits without disclosing confidential information. The interested person’s consent does not replace independent evaluation of the need to correct the scholarly record.
10. Confidentiality, enquiries and implementation
Declarations, clarifications, recusals and reasons for decisions are retained in secure editorial records with access granted on a need-to-know basis. Articles publish the information readers need to understand relevant interests; complete internal documents and personal data are not automatically disclosed. Confidentiality must not be used to omit a material public declaration.
Questions and reports are submitted through OJS or via the official editorial contact page, identifying the manuscript or publication and the specific circumstance. If the matter concerns the Editor-in-Chief or publisher, the independent procedure under the governance policy applies; the Institute’s official contacts are also available at https://tiiame.uz/. Appeals are considered by someone uninvolved in the contested decision, in accordance with the Complaints and Appeals Policy.
The policy takes effect following approval and official publication. Disclosures, assessments and updates are recorded with their actual dates. It complements the publication ethics rules; detailed procedures for peer review, governance, investigations and publication corrections appear on the relevant separate pages.
Reference guidance
The policy takes account of COPE and ICMJE guidance and the principles of transparency in scholarly publishing. The specific disclosure periods and organisational measures set out below are the journal’s own rules.
- ICMJE: Disclosure of Financial and Non-Financial Relationships and Activities, and Conflicts of Interest
- Elsevier: Publishing Ethics
- DOAJ: Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing
- COPE: Undisclosed conflict of interest in a submitted manuscript
- COPE: Undisclosed conflict of interest in a published article