Informed Consent Policy
Procedures for obtaining, documenting, updating and withdrawing informed consent to participate in research and separate consent to publish identifiable materials.
Contents
- Purpose and types of consent
- Information before decision-making
- Obtaining and documenting consent
- Decision-making support and representation
- Modification of procedures and waivers of consent
- Recordings, additional purposes and further use
- Separate consent for publication of identifiable materials
- Renewal and withdrawal of consent
- Retention of evidence and submission to the editorial office
- Article declarations and editorial verification
01. Purpose and types of consent
This policy defines how authors obtain and demonstrate informed consent in research submitted to the journal. It covers surveys, interviews, observations, interventions and the use of identifiable information or materials. The scope of ethics review and general protective measures are set out in the “Ethical Requirements for Research Involving Human Participants” section.
Consent is a process of understandable information-sharing and voluntary decision-making, not merely a signature. Consent to participate, consent to audio or video recording and specified uses of data, and separate consent to publish materials from which a person can be identified are distinguished. One form of consent does not replace another; where a single document is used, decisions are presented as separate, clearly identified items.
Permission from an employer, farm manager or community representative does not replace the decision of a participant capable of making it independently. An author's agreement to publish an article and acceptance of its licence do not constitute the research participants' consent. Obtaining consent does not relieve researchers of their duties to ensure safety and protect rights.
02. Information before decision-making
Before consent is obtained, participants receive accessible information in a language they understand and in a suitable format. The extent of the explanation is proportionate to the research; material conditions must not be hidden in complex legal language or disclosed only after participation has begun. Information materials must cover:
- the purpose of the research, responsible organisation, role of the research team and reason for inviting the relevant category of participants;
- expected participant activities, duration, questions, procedures and recordings; the experimental nature of interventions and available alternatives, where applicable;
- foreseeable inconveniences and risks, potential benefits without guarantees of results, costs, reimbursement and remuneration; for relevant medical research, care and compensation for research-related harm;
- information collected, purposes of use, persons with access, storage methods and retention period or criteria for determining it, planned transfer and further use;
- planned publication, extent of de-identification and reasonably foreseeable limits of confidentiality, including applicable disclosure obligations;
- the right to refuse, decline individual questions and discontinue participation, the procedure for requesting data deletion and known limitations of deletion;
- funding and conflicts of interest material to the decision, researchers' contact details and an independent channel for concerns about participants' rights.
The researcher provides an opportunity to ask questions, checks understanding of material conditions and allows sufficient time for a decision. Participants receive a copy of the information and their decision, or an accessible means of retaining them, unless this creates additional risk for them.
03. Obtaining and documenting consent
Consent is obtained before the relevant participation or use of information, except where an exemption has been properly authorised. It is obtained by a trained team member; where participants are dependent on a researcher, independent consent procedures established in the participant protection policy are applied. Silence and the absence of objections do not in themselves establish consent.
- Written consent: the project, version of information provided, agreed activities and date are recorded; signatures of the participant or authorised representative and the person obtaining consent are provided in accordance with the approved procedure.
- Electronic consent: an explicit action by the participant, an opportunity to review the conditions and ask questions, and a verifiable record of the date and version are required. Preselected checkboxes are unsuitable. Identity verification must be proportionate to risk and must not lead to excessive collection of identifiers.
- Oral consent: permitted when consistent with applicable requirements and the approved procedure. The research record documents the content of the decision, date and person obtaining consent; a witness or recording is used when required. For medical research, non-written consent must be witnessed and documented in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki.
- Anonymous questionnaire: completion may serve as an indication of consent only under a procedure justified in advance and approved where required, following an accessible explanation of conditions and voluntary choice. Submitting a form alone does not justify collecting information without informing participants.
Names or signatures should not be collected merely as a formality where this would undermine justified anonymity; a permissible alternative method is established before data collection. The process of obtaining consent must not itself be audio-recorded without informing the participant and obtaining necessary permission. Author registration in OJS and submission checklist confirmations do not replace participant consent.
04. Decision-making support and representation
Illiteracy, disability or a language barrier does not mean that a person lacks capacity to consent. Accessible formats, translation, additional explanation and, where necessary, independent assistance are provided. Interpreters and witnesses do not make decisions on the person's behalf and must preserve confidentiality.
Where applicable rules require a legal representative's decision, researchers verify the representative's authority and document its legal basis. The participant receives information at an accessible level and, if able to express it, their informed agreement is also sought to the extent of their understanding. Refusal or resistance is respected; a workplace supervisor does not become a legal representative merely by virtue of their position.
The age at which independent consent is permitted and any exceptions are determined by applicable rules, not by a single age threshold set by the journal. If a participant gains independent capacity or the legal right to consent, their own consent for continued participation is obtained promptly. If capacity is lost, further actions follow the approved protocol and the competent authority's requirements; an earlier signature cannot be treated as unconditional permission to continue any procedure.
05. Modification of procedures and waivers of consent
Exemption from ethics review, waiver of the requirement for a signed form and waiver of obtaining consent are distinct matters. A decision on each applicable exception, its scope and protective measures must be documented by a competent body before the relevant activity. A researcher, editor or reviewer cannot independently grant such an exemption.
When requesting a modification or waiver, researchers explain why the usual procedure is impossible or impracticable and consider less restrictive alternatives. For ordinary waivers in health-related research, CIOMS guidance specifies a combination of conditions: important social value, impossibility or impracticability without a waiver, and risk no greater than minimal. Additional legal and ethical requirements remain applicable. Saving time or wishing to increase response numbers is not sufficient in itself.
If deferred consent is permitted in an exceptional medical situation, it must have a specific legal basis and prior approval of the protocol; consent from a representative or from the participant after capacity is restored is sought at the earliest opportunity. This is not a general authorisation to conduct ordinary research without consent.
Research involving concealed methods is subject to additional restrictions under the participant protection policy. A waiver of research consent does not automatically permit publication of recognisable materials. A letter obtained later or a subsequent signature must not be represented as prior consent; authors report the actual sequence of events.
06. Recordings, additional purposes and further use
Optional audio and video recordings, follow-up contact and additional uses of data are presented as separate decisions. Refusing an optional component does not prevent participation in the main component. If recording or particular processing is genuinely necessary for a specific method, this is explained in advance together with available alternatives; such a procedure must not be described as optional.
Consent to one project does not authorise any subsequent research, disclosure of raw data or transfer to new recipients. Further use must remain within the stated purposes, access conditions and protective measures. If a new purpose falls outside the agreed scope, new consent or a properly authorised waiver is required before it is undertaken.
Broad consent for future research is possible only where there is an appropriate legal and ethical basis and an understandable description of the fields of use, restrictions, access governance and means for participants to raise concerns. It is not an unlimited waiver of rights. Conditions for open or restricted access to research materials are governed by the Data and Reproducibility Policy.
07. Separate consent for publication of identifiable materials
If research materials allow a participant to be reasonably identified, the journal requires separate written consent for publication, including a properly documented electronic form. This applies to recognisable photographs, videos, voice recordings, case descriptions and quotations that enable identification through context. Consent is required where there is reasonable doubt about anonymity. Unnecessary identifiers are removed even when consent exists.
Participants are shown the information and materials intended for publication in their anticipated context; when identifiable patient information is to be published, the patient is shown the manuscript. The consent document must identify the materials and version authorised. Any material expansion of identifiable content requires consent to be renewed.
Before the decision, participants are informed that the article will be openly available online and that the material may be distributed and reused. The journal applies CC BY 4.0: the licence allows reuse within the copyright permissions granted and subject to its conditions, but does not in itself override privacy or image rights. Consent to publication must not be framed as a waiver of all personal rights or a guarantee that copies held by others can be controlled.
Without the required consent, identifiable material is not published: it is removed or properly de-identified without distorting its scientific meaning. Inability to contact the person and silence do not constitute permission. For deceased participants, permissibility and the authority of a representative are assessed under applicable requirements rather than assumed family consent.
08. Renewal and withdrawal of consent
Consent is reviewed following material changes to procedures, risks, data use or the identifiable materials intended for publication. New information is provided before changed activities occur; where required, new consent and prior ethics committee approval are obtained. Refusal must not result in punishment or adverse treatment.
Withdrawal from participation, cessation of further data use and withdrawal of permission to publish are distinct requests. Researchers clarify the person's wishes, stop the relevant future activities and explain what can be deleted or must be retained on a mandatory basis. Following irreversible de-identification, identifying a particular record may be impossible; these limitations are explained before consent rather than introduced retrospectively.
If consent to identifiable publication is withdrawn before publication, authors promptly notify the editorial office; the relevant material is withheld until the matter is properly resolved. After publication, requests are assessed in light of personal rights and the rules on corrections and retractions, with privacy protection measures taken where necessary. Removal of all distributed copies cannot be promised, nor does every request automatically justify retracting the entire article.
09. Retention of evidence and submission to the editorial office
The research organisation and designated records custodian are responsible for the authenticity and preservation of evidence; the corresponding author ensures that the editorial office can verify it. Consent forms, coding keys and participant data are stored with restricted access. Retention periods and transfer of responsibility are determined by applicable requirements, the approved protocol and the Data and Reproducibility Policy, taking account of mandatory restrictions on retaining personal information.
The journal normally receives the authors' declaration and, on request, a blank specimen of the form or information sheet used. Signed documents containing personal information are not included in the article, public supplementary files or open repositories, and are not provided to reviewers unnecessarily.
If verification of a particular consent is necessary, the editorial office agrees on a secure and proportionate approach: confirmation from the responsible custodian, a redacted copy or other sufficient documentation. Complete forms are not sent through ordinary channels without prior agreement and adequate grounds. Under double-anonymous peer review, author-identifying information is submitted to the editorial office separately; participant data continue to be protected after publication.
10. Article declarations and editorial verification
Information on consent is included in the single research ethics compliance statement required by the Research Ethics Policy, with necessary explanations in the methods section. A separate duplicative section is not required. Authors state the method of consent and its documentation, representation where relevant, grounds for exceptions and whether separate consent for identifiable publication was obtained.
If consent was not required, the specific reason is explained, for example that the study did not involve people, identifiable information or materials. If consent would have been necessary but was waived by a competent body, that body, the date, reference number if available and scope of the decision are identified. “Not applicable” is not a substitute for information about a waiver, and ethics committee approval alone does not prove that consent was obtained.
The editorial office may request clarification and suspend consideration or publication pending verification. The absence of an explanation does not prove a breach, but failure to obtain necessary consent may prevent publication. Suspected false forms or declarations are handled under the Policy on Allegations of Misconduct; appeals are handled under the Complaints and Appeals Policy.
Participants, representatives and authors may contact the journal through its official editorial contact page, identifying the manuscript or article and the nature of the concern without excessive personal information. This policy does not retrospectively create consent that was never obtained: earlier research is assessed according to the requirements applicable at the time and the actual rights of participants.
Ethical and methodological guidance
The documents are applied with regard to the nature of the research and their respective scope. Medical guidance does not turn an ordinary survey or interview into medical research. This policy specifies consent procedures and applies alongside the journal's other research ethics policies.
- Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing
- WMA Declaration of Helsinki (2024)
- CIOMS International Ethical Guidelines for Health-related Research Involving Humans (2016)
- ESRC Research Ethics Guidance: Consent
- ESRC Research Ethics Guidance: Research with Children and Young People
- ICMJE Recommendations: Protection of Research Participants
- Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International (CC BY 4.0)