Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy

This policy defines the distribution of authority among the founder, publisher and editorial office, the procedure for making and delegating editorial decisions, and measures to protect scientific assessment from administrative, financial and personal influence.

01. Purpose and organisational framework

The founder of “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics” is the National Research University “Tashkent Institute of Irrigation and Agricultural Mechanization Engineers” (hereafter the Institute), and its publisher is I-EDU GROUP LLC. The Institute and publisher provide the organisational foundation for the journal’s activities, while the editorial office is responsible for the scientific assessment of materials and editorial decisions.

Editorial independence means the ability to make reasoned decisions within the journal’s published rules without improper interference by interested parties. It is combined with accountability for the quality of decisions, compliance with procedures and correction of identified errors.

The policy applies to all editorial materials and publication formats, including special issues and invited articles. An author’s affiliation with the Institute, position or relationship with the editorial office does not establish a special procedure for accepting an article.

02. Separation of responsibilities

  • The Institute and publisher provide funding, staffing and technical support, formalise appointments, maintain publishing infrastructure and fulfil accepted publishing obligations.
  • The Editor-in-Chief leads scientific and editorial work, ensures policies are applied, allocates editorial authority and is responsible for the quality-control system.
  • Authorised editors make decisions or prepare recommendations within documented assignments.
  • The editorial board advises on scientific development and quality; its composition and duties are governed by the separate Editorial Board Policy.

The Institute and publisher may discuss the budget, resources, overall strategy and organisational performance with the editorial office. These powers do not include selecting a preferred decision on a particular article, demanding acceptance of a manuscript or preventing publication of scientifically justified conclusions to protect reputational or commercial interests.

Changes in resources are discussed with the Editor-in-Chief, taking into account their consequences for current obligations. Funding, staffing decisions and technical access are not used to compel a particular editorial decision.

03. Appointment and accountability of the Editor-in-Chief

The Institute formally appoints the Editor-in-Chief following a documented assessment of relevant expertise, editorial experience, professional integrity and ability to fulfil the duties. Opinions of specialists without conflicts of interest are sought when considering candidates. Before appointment, candidates disclose significant interests and other editorial commitments.

New appointments and renewals following the entry into force of this policy have a three-year term. Authority, responsibilities, reporting arrangements, renewal conditions, termination procedures and dispute resolution are documented in writing. Reappointment is permitted following evaluation; automatic renewal does not apply.

Performance is evaluated at least once a year, considering procedural quality, justification of decisions, timeliness, handling of enquiries and accuracy of journal information. Revenue, acceptance rates and citation growth are not used as independent measures of editorial success.

Early termination requires documented grounds, notification of the editor and an opportunity to provide explanations. Good-faith refusal to accept a weak article, publication of justified criticism or reporting misconduct are not grounds for removal. Disputed circumstances are considered under the independent procedure in Section 7.

04. Editorial decisions and delegation

Decisions to send a manuscript for peer review, request revision, accept or reject are made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorised editor without conflicts of interest. Decisions are based on relevance to the scope, scientific soundness, quality of evidence and compliance with ethical requirements. The assessment process is established in the Peer Review Policy.

Delegation records the responsible editor, specific manuscript or area, scope of authority and any requirement for further approval. Authors must be able to identify who is responsible for the decision communicated to them. Delegating an assignment does not release the editorial office from responsibility for following procedures.

Recommendations from the board, reviewers and invited specialists are considered substantively but do not turn the decision into an administrative vote. An invitation to submit, a special-issue agreement or a manager’s instruction does not replace the prescribed assessment.

A decision may be reconsidered when material new information, an error or a justified appeal emerges, with reasons documented. When the Editor-in-Chief is recused, they neither approve nor overturn the decision of the appointed independent editor. The publisher does not replace an editorial appeal with an administrative order.

05. Separation of financial and technical functions

Editors deciding on an article do not handle its payment, fee waivers or individual financial agreements. These tasks are performed by a separately designated administrative employee or a unit of the Institute or publisher. Even with limited staffing, the functions are assigned to different individuals.

The level of support, source of expense coverage and an author’s financial circumstances do not influence reviewer selection, manuscript assessment or decisions. Editorial and staff remuneration is not based on acceptance of individual articles. Fee arrangements and expense coverage are published in a separate policy.

Technical specialists carry out approved operations involving the platform and materials. Administrative access to OJS does not confer authority to alter a scientific decision, substitute a review, delete objections or publish a manuscript without editorial authorisation.

06. Independent handling of conflicts of interest

Where a conflict of interest exists, authority is transferred to another competent editor. The Deputy Editor-in-Chief may perform this role only when independence has been confirmed; the title alone does not replace examination of actual relationships.

Where the author is the Editor-in-Chief, their immediate supervisor or another person on whom an internal editor depends professionally, a suitable editor from another organisation is appointed. The same approach applies when a research topic significantly affects institutional interests and internal recusal cannot ensure independence.

A board member without a conflict organises the selection of an external editor, checking expertise, relationships and written consent. The appointment, scope of authority and reasons for recusal are documented. The interested person does not choose the replacement editor or control the decision; the secretariat provides technical support.

Definitions of conflicts and disclosure obligations are set out in the Conflicts of Interest Policy. Procedures for independent peer review and disclosure of this handling in the article are governed by the Peer Review Policy.

07. Protection against pressure and dispute resolution

Demands to accept or reject an article for reasons unrelated to scientific assessment, threats of employment consequences, attempts to conceal material errors and interference with the selection of independent participants must be recorded. The editor retains relevant correspondence and reports interference through the official channel.

When a complaint concerns the Editor-in-Chief, it is referred to an independent responsible person rather than to that editor for substantive review. A complex dispute about editorial independence is examined by a group of at least three specialists; a majority, including the chair, must be external to the Institute and free from conflicts of interest. If the dispute concerns the Institute’s leadership, the entire group is external.

Parties to the dispute are informed of the review group’s composition and the procedure for presenting explanations; reasoned conflict-of-interest objections are checked before substantive consideration. Organisational support from the Institute does not entitle it to predetermine the group’s conclusions.

The group assesses compliance with authority and procedure and proposes measures such as eliminating interference, replacing a responsible person, restoring access or conducting a new independent review. It does not accept an article by administrative decision. Outcomes and measures are documented, and participants are informed within confidentiality requirements. Good-faith reporting must not lead to retaliation.

08. Access management and documentation

Editorial appointments, recusals, reasons for decisions and material changes are retained in OJS or another secure editorial record. Correcting a record must leave a traceable history; fabricated reviews, dates or confirmations are prohibited.

Access is granted on a need-to-know basis and reviewed when roles change, recusal occurs or duties end. Administrators’ technical capabilities are subject to organisational rules and activity logs; these capabilities do not constitute scientific authority. Confidential materials are not provided to management or financial staff solely because of their positions.

Automated tools may be used within the relevant policy and under human oversight. A tool does not become an independent party to an editorial decision. Detailed requirements for AI use, confidentiality and retention are established in separate documents.

09. Quality control and transparency

At least annually, the Editor-in-Chief provides the Institute and editorial board with an aggregated performance review covering procedural compliance, workload, timeliness, complaints, corrections and necessary improvements. Reporting does not require disclosure of anonymous reviewers’ identities or unrestricted access to manuscripts.

The website maintains current information about the founder, publisher, editors, their institutions and official contacts. Claims about timelines, membership, indexing and services must be verifiable. Public information reflects actual conditions, not merely planned capabilities.

Deviations from an announced publication schedule are recorded and explained on the basis of documentation. Issue history is published in the relevant website section; unknown reasons for missing issues are not replaced by assumptions. Scientific standards are not lowered to fill an issue.

10. Continuity and implementation of the policy

When the Editor-in-Chief changes or is temporarily unable to fulfil duties, the Institute formally appoints a competent acting editor with defined term and authority. Unfinished manuscripts, enquiries and necessary records are transferred with documentation. The appointment does not cancel earlier recusals or justify arbitrary reconsideration of decisions.

Changes to editorial rules are prepared with the participation of the Editor-in-Chief and board, aligned with organisational resources and published with their actual effective date. Material changes affecting manuscripts already submitted are communicated to the relevant authors. New rules are not used to present past work as meeting requirements that did not exist at the time.

This policy applies after approval and official publication. Peer review, board membership, conflicts of interest, complaints, ethics investigations and publication corrections are governed by their respective separate policies.

Official contact channel: Editorial contacts

The enquiry should specify whether it concerns editorial governance or independence. If using the editorial channel creates a conflict, a request for independent consideration under Section 7 may be sent through the official contacts of the Institute.

Reference guidance

The policy takes account of applicable international guidance. Specific governance procedures and terms of office are internal rules of the journal.

Back to top


ISSN 2181-4546 (Online)