Complaints and Appeals Policy
The journal provides a clear and fair procedure for handling submissions of concerns. This policy distinguishes complaints about the conduct of participants in the publishing process from appeals against editorial decisions and establishes procedures for submission, independent examination, response and subsequent review.
Contents
- Purpose and types of submissions
- Who may submit a complaint and grounds for consideration
- How and when to submit a complaint or appeal
- Responsible person and independent consideration
- Registration and initial assessment
- Substantive review of an appeal
- Investigation of complaints and establishment of facts
- Target timeframes and updates
- Outcome, further recourse and case closure
- Protection of participants, records and implementation
01. Purpose and types of submissions
This policy applies to “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics”, its editorial office, reviewers, editorial board members, guest editors, staff, its founder — the Institute — and its publisher — I-EDU GROUP LLC. It covers regular and special issues, the handling of manuscripts and materials already published.
A complaint concerns actions, omissions, the quality of editorial services or compliance with rules, for example an unexplained delay, inappropriate communication, a breach of confidentiality or a conflict of interest. An appeal is a reasoned request by an author to reconsider a specific editorial decision on a manuscript, including rejection before external peer review.
Concerns about plagiarism, data reliability, authorship and other possible misconduct are accepted through the same channels but investigated under the relevant specialist policies. If a submission raises several issues, the editorial office coordinates their consideration and informs the complainant which procedure applies to each.
02. Who may submit a complaint and grounds for consideration
An author, reviewer, reader, employee or another interested person or organisation may submit a complaint. A substantive anonymous report is also examined if it identifies the material and relevant circumstances. The absence of a name is not in itself grounds for rejection; without contact details, opportunities for clarification and notification are limited.
An appeal against an overall editorial decision is submitted by the corresponding author with the agreement of all coauthors. This requirement does not restrict any coauthor's right to separately report misconduct, an authorship dispute or the actions of another coauthor.
- A significant factual or technical error in the assessment of a manuscript.
- Materials already provided during review but not considered, which could have affected the decision.
- A breach of the announced procedure, unjustified differences in applying rules or indications of bias.
- An unresolved conflict of interest involving an editor or reviewer that could have influenced the decision.
Mere disagreement with an assessment of novelty or significance, a request to accelerate career advancement or reference to expenses incurred are insufficient grounds. Substantially revised research with new results is usually treated as a new submission if the editorial office permits it; this does not prove that the assessment of the previous version was incorrect.
03. How and when to submit a complaint or appeal
A submission is sent through the manuscript correspondence in OJS or through the editorial contact information on the journal's official website. The subject line should state “Complaint” or “Appeal” and the manuscript number; for a published article, give the title and DOI or link. A duplicate submission of the same manuscript is not required to register the complaint or appeal.
- Provide contact details for a response, your relationship to the material and the date of the challenged decision or event.
- Describe the specific circumstances and, where known, the rule that may have been breached.
- Attach relevant documents, correspondence, links and a coherent explanation of the arguments; for an appeal, include responses to disputed points in the editor's or reviewer's assessment.
- State the desired outcome, such as correction of a technical error, an explanation of a delay or independent reconsideration of a decision.
An appeal must be submitted within 30 calendar days of receiving the decision. In the event of a justified delay, such as late discovery of a material circumstance or a documented obstacle, an independent handling editor may accept it later, recording the reason. There is no such deadline for complaints concerning publication reliability, ethics or misconduct; prompt reporting after discovery is recommended.
Submissions are accepted in Russian, English and Uzbek. Examination of a complaint or appeal is free of charge. Complainants may request confidential handling of their identity and explain the risks associated with disclosure.
04. Responsible person and independent consideration
After checking interests, a competent person who did not participate in the contested decision and is not implicated in the complaint is appointed. An appeal concerning scientific assessment is handled by an authorised independent editor; the employee registering the correspondence does not thereby gain authority to decide a scientific matter. Participants in the original assessment may provide explanations but do not decide complaints about their own actions.
If a submission concerns the Editor-in-Chief, it is referred to an editorial board member without a conflict of interest to organise independent consideration under the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy. A deputy may participate only in the absence of a conflict and prior involvement; where an employment or institutional dependency exists, an external editor is appointed. An interested manager neither selects the reviewer of the complaint nor approves their conclusions.
If submitting through the editorial office is difficult, the Institute's official contacts at https://tiiame.uz/ may be used, specifying the need for independent consideration. If the publisher or Institute leadership is implicated, the external review process and, where necessary, independent committee provided for in the governance policy apply. An administrative decision by the founder does not replace an editor's scientific decision.
The complainant is informed who is responsible for the review and may raise a reasoned objection to that person's involvement. Another independent person assesses the objection; the complainant does not appoint an editor or select the committee's membership.
05. Registration and initial assessment
The editorial office records the date of receipt and assigns a case number, acknowledges receipt and communicates the next stage. It checks relevance, sufficiency of information, applicable procedures and the need for urgent measures. An incorrect designation of the submission is not grounds for rejection: it is assigned to the appropriate procedure and the complainant is notified.
If information is insufficient, specific clarification is requested and a reasonable deadline, usually 10 working days, is set; a justified request for an extension is considered. If the complainant does not respond, the case may be closed with an explanation of the insufficient evidence. Silence is not proof of misconduct, and significant indications of risk to publication reliability are assessed on the available information.
An obvious threat to confidentiality, participants' safety or the reliability of material intended for publication is assessed without waiting for the normal deadline. Temporary restriction of access or suspension of publication must be proportionate and documented; it does not constitute a finding of guilt.
06. Substantive review of an appeal
The independent editor compares the original manuscript version, decision, reviews, authors' responses and submitted arguments with the rules in force during the initial assessment. Where necessary, explanations and a new expert evaluation are requested. The opinion of a person whose impartiality is contested is not the sole basis for the outcome.
An appeal does not disclose anonymous reviewers' identities to authors or permit circumvention of quality requirements. Reopening consideration does not guarantee acceptance: the Peer Review Policy's requirements, including the necessary number of independent assessments, remain mandatory. If an appeal is upheld only on procedural grounds, the procedure is corrected and the scientific outcome is determined by subsequent assessment.
While a manuscript appeal is under consideration, authors do not submit the manuscript to another journal. To submit it elsewhere, the corresponding author gives written notice withdrawing the appeal; the editorial office records and confirms its termination without requiring consent to the withdrawal itself. If the manuscript is already under consideration by another journal, this is disclosed and the appeal to reopen consideration is terminated. A report of possible ethical misconduct may nevertheless continue to be investigated.
07. Investigation of complaints and establishment of facts
The responsible person reviews correspondence, OJS records and relevant documents. The person whose actions are questioned is informed of the substance of the allegation and given an opportunity to respond, normally within 10 working days, with an extension possible where justified. The complainant's identity and third-party information are disclosed only to the extent necessary.
The parties have an opportunity to comment on substantial new information that may support an adverse finding, subject to confidentiality and participant protection. An allegation, a participant's status or failure to respond does not replace evaluation of the evidence. Research misconduct matters are referred under the Policy on Allegations of Misconduct; the editorial office does not replace an investigation by an authorised research organisation.
A service complaint may lead to resolving a delay, correcting a technical error or changing working procedures. Problems identified in a published article are addressed under the Corrections, Retractions and Post-Publication Updates Policy. Submission or withdrawal of a complaint, or an appeal, does not automatically suspend measures necessary to protect the integrity of the scholarly record.
08. Target timeframes and updates
- Acknowledgement of receipt: within 5 working days of receiving the submission.
- Initial assessment and notice of the review procedure: within 10 working days of receipt.
- Ordinary substantive decision: target period of 30 working days after sufficient information has been received.
- Extension: the complainant is informed of the reason, actions taken within permissible limits and the next expected response date; a status update is provided at least once every 30 calendar days.
These are internal operational targets of the journal, not a guaranteed external investigation deadline or article acceptance date. Working days are Monday to Friday, excluding official public holidays in Uzbekistan. The need for expert assessment or an organisation's response may extend the period but does not remove the obligation to provide updates.
Requests for missing information must be specific; a minor clarification is not used to restart the deadline without justification. If acknowledgement or a scheduled response is not received on time, the complainant may follow up using the case number and then use the independent channel described in Section 4.
09. Outcome, further recourse and case closure
The complainant receives a written response setting out the main established facts, findings on the arguments, reasons, measures taken and procedure for further recourse. Confidential expert materials, personal data and information about staffing measures are not disclosed in full. Affected participants receive information relevant to them.
- Uphold the editorial decision or find the complaint unsubstantiated, with reasons.
- Uphold the submission wholly or partly: correct an error, replace a participant, reopen consideration or commission an independent reassessment.
- Refer a specific issue to a specialist procedure or competent organisation, informing the complainant of the reason and further contact where known.
As a rule, one substantive appeal is permitted against a particular editorial decision. Once it is completed, repetition of earlier arguments does not initiate another review. However, significant new evidence, a previously unknown conflict or a serious defect in the appeal procedure itself may justify reopening; another independent person decides this.
A complaint about the handling of the complaint or appeal itself is referred through the independent channel in Section 4. Completion of the internal procedure does not restrict the right to contact a competent external organisation or prevent correction of a publication on new grounds. The closure decision and reasons are recorded; repeated submissions without new facts may be consolidated with an already closed case.
10. Protection of participants, records and implementation
A good-faith submission must not result in rejection of future submissions, unfavourable treatment, threats or other retaliatory measures. An unsubstantiated complaint does not in itself constitute abuse. In cases of threats or insults, the editorial office may limit the form of communication while maintaining a safe channel and consideration of the substantive concerns; the reason for the restriction is communicated and recorded.
Access to case materials is granted on a need-to-know basis. The editorial office protects the complainant's identity where possible but does not promise absolute anonymity: identity may be inferable from the circumstances or disclosure may be necessary for a fair investigation or mandatory reporting. Where feasible and permitted, the need to disclose identity is discussed with the complainant in advance; only the minimum necessary information is shared.
The complaint, dates, documents, recusals, appointments of responsible persons, responses and grounds for decisions are retained in secure records. Retention periods and personal data processing are governed by the Privacy Statement. Aggregated anonymised outcomes are used to improve journal operations; complaint materials do not automatically become public.
The policy applies following approval and official publication. Actions and updates are recorded with their actual dates. Transition to a new version of the rules is not used to shorten a previously granted submission period or retrospectively justify violations.
Reference guidance
The principles of transparency of DOAJ and COPE and publishers' general approaches to considering appeals have been taken into account. The scope, timeframes and organisational arrangements below are established by the journal itself; other publishers' rules are not automatically adopted.