Allegations of Misconduct Policy
Substantiated reports of possible misconduct are examined before and after publication. This policy defines procedures for preserving and assessing evidence, obtaining explanations, cooperating with research institutions and taking proportionate editorial measures to protect the reliability of the scholarly record.
Contents
- Purpose and limits of authority
- Reports subject to examination
- Reporting and initial assessment
- Independent oversight of the investigation
- Preservation and assessment of evidence
- Obtaining and examining explanations
- Cooperation with research institutions
- Editorial measures and grounds for decisions
- Continuation of the investigation and communication
- Documentation, reconsideration and implementation
01. Purpose and limits of authority
This policy applies to all types of materials in “Geodesy, Cartography and Geoinformatics”, including special issues, and covers possible misconduct by authors, reviewers, editors, editorial board members, staff and the publisher. An investigation may be conducted at any stage of manuscript consideration and after publication.
The editorial office is responsible for determining whether the material and its assessment procedure are reliable and for making decisions about manuscripts or published articles. A research institution investigates how the research was conducted, the actions of its employees and matters of disciplinary responsibility. The editorial office does not replace the institution's authority; nevertheless, the presence or absence of an institutional finding does not remove the obligation to protect the reliability of publications.
A report of misconduct provides grounds for assessment, not proof of guilt. Honest errors, scholarly disagreement, insufficiently substantiated conclusions and deliberate manipulation are distinguished. Establishing intent is not required to correct an unreliable publication; a public allegation of misconduct requires its own evidentiary basis.
02. Reports subject to examination
- Suspected fabrication or falsification of data, results, images, calculations or descriptions of methods, or significant unjustified concealment of results.
- Plagiarism, undisclosed duplicate publication, improper use of others' materials or misrepresentation of authorship and contributions.
- Fabricated reviews, reviewer identities or contact details, collusion, citation manipulation and other interference with independent assessment.
- False information concerning ethical approval, consent, permissions, funding or significant interests; violations of research ethics requirements.
- Use of AI tools in violation of the applicable policy, including generating fictitious data or references presented as genuine.
- Abuse of editorial authority, disclosure or appropriation of confidential materials, pressure and obstruction of an investigation; indications of systematic publication manipulation.
This list is not exhaustive. Criteria for authorship, textual borrowing, permitted AI use, conflicts of interest and research ethics are defined in the respective separate policies. Complaints solely about editorial services and appeals against scientific assessment without indications of misconduct are handled under the Complaints and Appeals Policy.
03. Reporting and initial assessment
Reports may be submitted through OJS or through the official editorial contact page. Assessment requires the manuscript identifier or the article title, DOI or link, a description of the specific concern and available supporting evidence, such as comparable passages, an original source, or a discrepancy in a table or image. The reporter is not required to conduct a complete investigation or prove intent independently.
Substantive anonymous reports and substantiated information identified by the editorial office in public discussions are also assessed. The reporting channel, the reporter's reputation or disagreements with an author do not replace an evaluation of the facts. Lack of contact details may limit clarification but does not end investigation of specific significant indications.
Registration, acknowledgment of receipt, target deadlines for initial assessment and protection of reporters are governed by the Complaints and Appeals Policy. There is no deadline for reporting a threat to the reliability of a publication. The initial stage establishes whether the concern is verifiable and significant, the applicable rules and the need for urgent protective measures; a general expression of dissatisfaction without specifics requires clarification.
04. Independent oversight of the investigation
A competent editor without a conflict of interest handles the case. If that editor's own decision or conduct is being examined, the editor provides explanations but does not oversee the investigation or approve its outcome. Recusal and appointment of another editor, external where necessary, are governed by the governance and conflicts of interest policies.
In complex cases, independent experts in the research subject, statistics, images or methods may be engaged, as may a committee in accordance with the Editorial Governance and Editorial Independence Policy. Experts and the committee assess the matters referred to them; the final decision concerning publication rests with an authorised independent editor.
If the Editor-in-Chief, publisher or Institute leadership is implicated, the independent procedure under the Complaints and Appeals Policy applies, including contact through the Institute's official channels at https://tiiame.uz/. Institutional dependence is addressed through external review; a person implicated in a report does not choose those examining their own actions.
05. Preservation and assessment of evidence
The initial report, the manuscript or article version under examination, files, revision history, reviews, correspondence and related editorial records are preserved. The source and date of each received item are recorded; working copies and findings are kept separate from originals. Access is restricted to those involved in the investigation on a need-to-know basis.
Where reasonably necessary, original data, measurement logs, original images, calculation files, code, protocols, permits or evidence of contributions are requested. For research in irrigation and melioration, these may include raw sensor readings, field experiment records, calibration information and model validation records. The request must explain the relevance of the materials to the specific concern and must not encompass unnecessary personal or commercially sensitive information.
Restricted data are transferred through an agreed secure channel or examined through an authorised organisation; public disclosure of confidential source materials is not required. An inability to provide older data is assessed in light of the retention requirements in force, circumstances of loss and alternative evidence. It does not automatically prove falsification, but may leave significant conclusions unverifiable.
Text-similarity scores, AI detector alerts and automated image-analysis findings are grounds for substantive investigation, not evidence in themselves. Findings are compared with original materials, explanations and qualified expert assessment. Rules are assessed according to their applicability at the time of the relevant actions; new formal requirements are not imposed retrospectively.
06. Obtaining and examining explanations
The person concerned receives a neutral description of the specific concerns, relevant materials and requested explanations without premature accusation. For an article, the corresponding author is generally contacted first; where necessary, other coauthors are contacted and individual responses obtained. One author's position is not automatically presented as that of all authors.
Response deadlines and the possibility of justified extensions are determined by the Complaints and Appeals Policy. In the absence of a reply, the editorial office sends a reminder, checks available current contact details and contacts coauthors or the research institution where necessary. Silence is not an admission of guilt; decisions are based on available evidence and assessment of the material's reliability.
Significant new information that could lead to an adverse finding is provided to the person concerned for comment to the extent compatible with protecting the reporter and third parties. Where there is a specific risk of destruction of evidence or pressure, initial notification may be postponed on a limited basis: the reason is recorded, information is referred to an independent competent body, and the right to respond is ensured as soon as the risk permits.
07. Cooperation with research institutions
Where there are serious substantiated concerns, unsatisfactory explanations or a need for verification beyond the editorial office's capacity, a reasoned request is sent to the person responsible for research integrity at the institution where the research was conducted or to another competent body. Where several institutions are involved, cooperation is coordinated. If the internal recipient has an interest in the outcome, an independent examination is requested.
The request distinguishes established facts from matters requiring investigation. Only necessary materials are shared, and acknowledgment of receipt, the responsible person's contact details, expected deadlines and findings relevant to the reliability or attribution of the publication are requested. Authors are generally notified of the referral; limits on notification are permitted in the circumstances described in Section 6.
If the institution does not respond, cannot conduct an independent investigation or its findings fail to explain material inconsistencies, the editorial office seeks clarification, continues assessing available evidence and, if necessary, engages external experts or refers the matter to another competent body. The lack of a response or the institution's agreement does not oblige the editorial office to leave clearly unreliable material unchanged.
If the facts affect publications in other journals, limited confidential communication with their responsible editors may be undertaken to investigate a shared concern. Verifiable information, not lists of “guilty” persons, is shared; the scope and purpose of the exchange are documented with due regard for data protection. A shared author or institutional affiliation does not in itself establish misconduct in other works.
08. Editorial measures and grounds for decisions
- The concern has been satisfactorily explained: the case is closed with reasons; manuscript consideration continues under ordinary criteria. A previously published warning is updated where necessary.
- A localised error with the work remaining reliable: a correction is requested before publication; after publication, a correction notice linked to the article is issued.
- A serious concern remains unresolved: manuscript consideration or release may be suspended; for a published article, an expression of concern may be considered on sufficient grounds, followed by a status review.
- Reliability is substantially compromised or a serious breach of publication requirements is established: the manuscript may be rejected or the published article retracted under the applicable policy with specific reasons.
- Misconduct involves an editor, reviewer or staff member: the person is removed from the affected process, the need for independent reassessment of works is evaluated, and any question concerning further authority is referred under governance rules.
Measures are proportionate to the established impact and scale of the problem. Retraction is not used as a punishment and is not imposed solely because of a complaint, an author's silence or the absence of a particular document. If the reliability of results has been seriously lost, an honest error does not preclude retraction. Each affected work is assessed individually, including in cases of suspected systematic manipulation.
Rules for selecting and issuing corrections, expressions of concern and retractions are set out in the Corrections, Retractions and Post-Publication Updates Policy. A public notice describes the confirmed problem and does not attribute equal culpability to all coauthors without grounds. Reliable findings about a publication's status may require action before an institutional investigation concludes; authors' consent is not a prerequisite for a justified editorial decision.
09. Continuation of the investigation and communication
Rejection, withdrawal of a manuscript by its author or withdrawal of a report by the reporter does not automatically end the examination of a significant risk. If the work has already been published elsewhere, the editorial office may pass relevant information to the responsible editor as described in Section 7. The process must not be used to retain a manuscript without justification or to pressure the author.
In complex cases, the timeframe depends on the scope of the investigation and the need for expert and institutional responses. Acknowledgments of receipt, extension notices and the frequency of status updates continue to be governed by the Complaints and Appeals Policy; awaiting an external investigation does not mean communication ceases. The responsible editor documents next steps and regularly assesses whether an interim notice to readers is necessary.
The reporter and affected participants are informed of the outcome and main reasons to the permissible extent. The public availability of a correction does not mean all investigative materials are open. Details of personal, disciplinary and other confidential matters are communicated only to recipients with the appropriate authority.
10. Documentation, reconsideration and implementation
The final record includes the matters investigated, evidence used, responses, disclosed interests, appointments and recusals, reasons for decisions and measures taken. If a final finding cannot be reached, the record specifies what remains unestablished and when the matter will be reconsidered. Preservation of materials and handling of personal data are governed by the Privacy Statement.
A decision or investigation procedure may be appealed under the Complaints and Appeals Policy; the appeal is assessed by someone uninvolved in the contested decision. Significant new information may lead to reopening the case. Reconsideration does not automatically justify delaying necessary notification to readers about the reliability of the work.
Protection of good-faith reporters and prohibition of retaliation remain in force whether or not their concerns are confirmed. The editorial office uses identified shortcomings to improve procedures and train participants without unnecessarily disclosing personal information.
The policy applies after approval and official publication, with actual dates of actions recorded. It may be used to investigate previously published materials but does not create a false history of past checks or silently alter the published scholarly record.
Reference guidance
This policy has been developed taking account of DOAJ transparency principles and COPE guidance on investigating possible misconduct, cooperating with research institutions and correcting publications. It establishes the journal's procedures and does not replace an institutional investigation.
- DOAJ: Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing
- COPE: Cooperation between Research Institutions and Journals on Research Integrity and Publication Misconduct Cases
- COPE: Fabricated Data in a Submitted Manuscript
- COPE: Fabricated Data in a Published Article
- COPE: Retraction Guidelines